What this calculator does
Municipal bonds usually pay a lower yield than taxable bonds, but their interest is free of federal income tax. This calculator shows the taxable yield you'd need to earn to keep the same amount after tax, so you can compare a muni bond or fund fairly with a CD, Treasury or corporate bond.
How to use it
- Enter the tax-free yield (%) of the municipal bond or fund.
- Enter your federal tax bracket (%): your top rate, not your average rate, since the interest is added on top of your other income.
- Enter your state tax rate (%).
- Tick also free of state tax (an in-state bond) if the bond is issued in your own state. Out-of-state munis are usually taxed by your state.
- Read the tax-equivalent yield and the combined tax rate.
How it's worked out
- Share you keep = (1 − federal rate), multiplied by (1 − state rate) when the bond is also state tax-free.
- Tax-equivalent yield = tax-free yield ÷ share you keep.
- Combined tax rate = 1 − share you keep.
Multiplying the two rates, rather than adding them, gives a combined rate a little lower than the plain sum. When the bond isn't state tax-free, only the federal rate is used, because the state taxes both bonds in that case. The calculator also shows the yearly income on each $1,000 at the tax-free yield.
Examples
Example 1: An in-state muni in the 24% bracket. A 3.5% in-state muni, with a 24% federal bracket and 5% state tax, matches a taxable yield of 4.85%. The combined tax rate is 27.8%, and each $1,000 earns $35.00 a year, tax-free.
Example 2: An out-of-state muni in the 32% bracket. A 3% muni from another state only saves the federal tax, so the combined rate is 32%. It's worth the same as a 4.41% taxable bond. If a CD pays more than that, the CD leaves you more after tax.
Tips and common mistakes
- Using your average tax rate. Bond interest is taxed at your top bracket, so use that. In a low bracket, munis rarely win.
- Treasuries are state tax-free too. When comparing a muni with a Treasury, the Treasury already avoids state tax, so the muni's edge is only federal.
- Some munis aren't fully tax-free. Private-activity bonds can count for the alternative minimum tax, and selling at a gain is still taxable.
- Yield isn't everything. Compare credit quality, call features and how long until maturity.
- A tax professional or financial adviser can help if your income is near a bracket edge.
- To see what a taxable CD earns, try the CD calculator. To check your bracket, use the income tax calculator.