Skip to content
Press Equals

Pension vs Lump Sum Calculator

$2,500 a month for 25 years is worth $427,650 today at a 5% return, more than a $400,000 lump sum. The lump sum needs 5.68% a year to match.

Compare a monthly pension with a lump-sum offer: what the payments are worth today, the return the lump sum needs, and how long it would last.

Result

Ignores taxes, survivor benefits and the pension insurer (PBGC). A pension also protects against outliving your money.

Worth more at this return

The pension

Pension's value today
$427,650.12
Lump sum offer
$400,000.00
Difference
$27,650.12
Return the lump sum needs to match
5.68%
Lump sum lasts, paying the pension amount
22.1years
Total pension payments
$750,000.00
How it’s worked out
  1. Pension value today = each of 300 monthly payments of $2,500.00 ÷ (1 + 5% ÷ 12)^month = $427,650.12
  2. Against the $400,000.00 lump sum, the lump sum would need to earn 5.68% a year to match

What this calculator does

When an employer offers a lump sum instead of a monthly pension, this calculator puts both on the same footing. It works out what the pension payments are worth today, compares that with the offer, and shows the return the lump sum would need to earn to match.

How to use it

  1. Enter the monthly pension ($) you've been offered.
  2. Enter the years you expect to collect. Life expectancy at 65 is roughly 18 to 22 years; use longer if your family tends to live long.
  3. Enter the yearly cost-of-living raise (%), or 0 if the pension is fixed.
  4. Enter the lump sum offer ($).
  5. Enter the return you could earn on the lump sum (%). A safe, realistic rate, like 4% to 6%, is a fair test.
  6. Read which is worth more, the difference and the break-even return.

How it's worked out

  • Pension's value today: each monthly payment is discounted back to today at your return ÷ 12 per month, and the results are added. With a cost-of-living raise, payments step up once a year.
  • Return the lump sum needs to match: the rate at which the pension's value today equals the lump sum exactly, found by trial.
  • Lump sum lasts: the lump sum grows at your return each month while you pay yourself the pension amount, until it runs out.

Whichever is larger at your chosen return is worth more. A higher return favors the lump sum; a longer life favors the pension. Taxes, survivor benefits and pension insurance (PBGC) aren't included.

Examples

Example 1: $2,500 a month or $400,000. At a 5% return, 25 years of $2,500 a month is worth $427,650.12 today, so The pension is worth more. The $400,000 would need to earn 5.68% a year to keep up.

Example 2: A smaller pension with raises. $1,800 a month rising 2% a year for 20 years, against $300,000 at 6%: The lump sum is ahead by $6,398.84. Paying yourself the same rising income, it lasts 20.8 years, barely past the 20 you planned for.

Tips and common mistakes

  • Using an optimistic return. At 8% almost any lump sum looks better. A bad market early in retirement can drain it far faster than an average return suggests.
  • Underestimating how long you'll live. The pension pays for life. The lump sum doesn't.
  • Ignoring a spouse. A joint-and-survivor pension keeps paying after you die; compare that option too.
  • Taxes on the lump sum. Roll it directly into an IRA to avoid tax now. Cashing it out can push you into a high bracket.
  • This choice is usually permanent. A fee-only financial planner can check your full situation before you sign.
  • To see how a pension is calculated, use the pension calculator. For buying guaranteed income with a lump sum, try the annuity calculator.

Common questions

Should I take the pension or the lump sum?

Compare the lump sum with what the pension is worth today. $2,500 a month for 25 years is worth $427,650 at a 5% return, more than a $400,000 offer; the lump sum would need to earn 5.68% a year to match.

What does the pension give me that the math misses?

Income for as long as you live, however long that is, plus survivor benefits if you choose them, and PBGC insurance for most private pensions.

When is the lump sum better?

With poor health or a short life expectancy, a pension plan in financial trouble, or when you want to leave the money to heirs.

How we check this calculator

  • Tested against 3 reference answers worked from published sources or by hand,such as “PV of 300 payments of 2500 at 5%/12 = 2500 × 171.06”.
  • All 2 worked examples in the article above are run through this calculator, so the two can't disagree.
  • Every input is tried at its smallest and largest values and with random numbers, and must never crash or show a broken number.
  • These checks run automatically before any change goes live.

Spotted a wrong number? Tell us and we'll fix it. See how the calculators are tested.

Updated