What this calculator does
This calculator shows what it costs to convert money from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA this year, and whether it pays off later. It works out the extra federal and state tax the conversion adds, then compares the Roth at retirement with leaving the money where it is.
How to use it
- Enter the amount to convert ($).
- Enter your other income this year ($): your gross income before converting, like wages.
- Choose your filing status.
- Enter your state income tax rate (%), or 0 if your state has none.
- Enter the years until you withdraw and a yearly return (%).
- Enter your expected tax rate when you withdraw (%), federal plus state.
- Read the tax on the conversion, the effective rate on it, and the gain (or loss) from converting.
How it's worked out
- Tax on the conversion = federal tax on (other income + conversion − standard deduction) − federal tax on (other income − standard deduction), plus conversion × state rate. It uses the 2026 federal brackets and standard deduction.
- If you convert, the full amount grows tax-free: conversion × (1 + return)^years.
- If you don't, the IRA grows at the same return and is taxed at your later rate when you withdraw. The calculator assumes the conversion tax is paid from savings outside the IRA, so in this case that money stays invested and also grows at the same return. It's added to the "don't convert" side.
Converting comes out ahead when your later tax rate is higher than the rate you pay on the conversion now.
Examples
Example 1: A married couple converting $50,000. With $90,000 of other income and no state tax, converting $50,000 adds $6,700.00 of tax, a 13.4% rate on the converted money. If they'd pay 22% on withdrawals in 20 years, converting is ahead by $16,639.64.
Example 2: When converting doesn't pay. A single filer earning $60,000 with 5% state tax pays $7,450.00 to convert $30,000, a 24.83% rate. With an expected 24% rate later, the answer is Not converting comes out ahead, by a small margin.
Tips and common mistakes
- Paying the tax from the IRA itself shrinks what gets converted and can trigger a 10% penalty before age 59½. The math here assumes you pay from other savings.
- Converting in pieces over several low-income years can keep each slice in a lower bracket.
- Watch side effects. Extra income can raise Medicare premiums, reduce credits or push up the tax on Social Security. The calculator doesn't include these.
- Each conversion has its own five-year clock for penalty-free withdrawal of the converted amount if you're under 59½. Talk to a tax professional before a large conversion.
- To compare Roth and traditional for new savings, use the Roth vs traditional 401(k) calculator. For required withdrawals later, see the RMD calculator.