What this calculator does
This calculator answers a common workplace question: should your 401(k) contributions go in as Roth (taxed now) or traditional (taxed later)? It compares the two at the same take-home cost, then shows what each is worth after tax at retirement and which comes out ahead.
How to use it
- Enter the Roth contribution per year ($): what you would put in on the Roth side.
- Enter the years until retirement.
- Enter a yearly return (%). The same return is used for both accounts.
- Enter your tax rate now (%): your federal bracket plus your state rate.
- Enter your expected tax rate in retirement (%).
- Read which one comes out ahead, by how much, and each account's value after tax.
How it's worked out
A Roth dollar costs a full dollar of take-home pay. A traditional dollar costs less, because it comes out before tax. So for the same hit to your paycheck, the traditional side can put in more:
- Traditional deposit = Roth contribution ÷ (1 − tax rate now)
Each account gets its deposit at the end of every year and grows at your return. The Roth balance is yours tax-free. The traditional balance is multiplied by (1 − retirement tax rate) to get what you keep. In the end, the winner is simply whichever tax rate is lower: now (Roth) or later (traditional).
If the traditional deposit would be over the yearly 401(k) limit, the calculator says so. Near the limit, Roth shelters more money. Employer matches go in pre-tax either way and aren't part of this comparison.
Examples
Example 1: Lower tax rate in retirement. $10,000 a year in a Roth for 30 years at 7% grows to $944,607.86. The same take-home cost buys a $12,820.51 traditional deposit, which is worth $1,029,380.36 after a 15% tax in retirement. The Traditional 401(k) comes out ahead by $84,772.50.
Example 2: Low bracket now, higher later. At a 12% rate now, $6,000 of Roth costs the same as $6,818.18 of traditional. If you expect to pay 22% later, the Roth 401(k) wins by $43,124.34 after 25 years.
Tips and common mistakes
- Comparing equal deposits instead of equal cost. $10,000 Roth and $10,000 traditional don't cost the same. The traditional saving only counts if you actually invest it, which putting the bigger amount in the 401(k) does.
- Guessing your retirement rate. Nobody knows future tax law. Many people split contributions between both to hedge.
- Forgetting state tax. Moving to a no-tax state in retirement favors traditional; moving to a high-tax one favors Roth.
- A tax professional can help if your income is near a bracket edge or you expect large pensions or required withdrawals.
- To project a full 401(k) with raises and a match, use the 401(k) calculator. For an IRA, try the Roth IRA calculator or the Roth conversion calculator.